Make your own free website on Tripod.com
Congressional Gold Medal 4 Bataan POW
Request to Amend H.R. 2598
Home
S. 768
Request to Amend S768
Call to Action S.768
H. R. 2598
Request to Amend H.R. 2598
Call To Action H.R. 2598
Filvets Bataan POWs Names A to L
Filvets Bataan POWs Names M to Z
What is CG Medal?
List of CG Medal Recipients (1776-1900)
List of CG Medal Recipients (1901-2008)
H.R. 5315 (previous bill for CGMedal)
H.R. 423 Death March Compensation Act
Return Our Balangiga Bells

let us run with endurance the race that is set before us Hebrews 12:1

https://garamendi.house.gov/htbin/formproc.pl?/garamendi/email-me.txt&display=/garamendi/contact/email-me-thankyou.shtml&nobase

 

Email Me - Thank You

The following information has been submitted:

An Open Letter to Congressman John Garamendi Seeking to Request Sponsorship of Amendment to HR 2598 for the Inclusion of the WW11 POWs from the Philippines

 

Dear Cong. Garamendi:

 

Sir, during this solemn occasion when we, Americans publicly honor the service and sacrifice of our military, allow me to plead with you to sponsor an amendment to HR 2598 introduced by Cong Martin Heinrich of New Mexico on May 21, 2009.  HR 2598 seeks to award the Congressional Gold Medal to WW11 U.S. military personnel from the United States. Excluded in the bill were those WW11 U.S. military personnel from the Philippines.

 

Undoubtedly, HR 2598 as currently written is unconstitutional for treating soldiers who are similarly situated (same U.S. command, same POW camp, same fate-and that is dying) not in similar manner, by awarding medals to those who came from the U.S. and excluding those who came from the Philippines.  As we all know, equity is rooted in conscience. This is the fundamental belief that every soldiers had fought for all of us.  Most important, legislative bills when crafted and before they are passed into Public Laws must be based on equity

 

Amending HR 2598 is not an economic issue of additional cost to the U.S. government since only one gold medal will be awarded collectively & symbolically to all recipients. Duplicate bronze medals will be sold after the entire cost has been factored into a specified sale price. Therefore, it would even be a brilliant marketing strategy to have more recipients in order to generate a robust sale. The adage, the more the merrier holds true in this situation. Incidentally, the profit shall be deposited in favor of the U.S. Mint Public Enterprise Fund.

 

Amending HR 2598 is not prohibited because of the citizenship, nationality or domicile of recipients, since these has never been issues in the past and the Medal has been granted to many individuals of various citizenship, nationality & domicile

 

Since May 27, 2009 I had communicated my concerns to Cong Heinrich via e-mails and phone calls that were validated by his office staff as received.  Cong. Heinrich has been silent as to the cause of the exclusion of the Filipino veterans

 

Therefore, in honor of those who perished, the survivors, the departed, many dying with war wounds that never healed because of the bitterness of the inequity, I plead with you to kindly respond in the affirmative that you will file an amendment to include the soldiers from the Philippines in HR 2598 .  Never should we forget again to whom we all owe the freedom that we all enjoy today.

 

Your honor, my deepest gratitude to you and your staff.

 

 

Sincerely,

Maria Elizabeth Embry

xxxx

Antioch Ca 94509

Tel xxxx

November 11, 2009 Veterans’ Day

 

Enclosures:

 

An Open e- letter to the Honorable Representative Martin Heinrich of New Mexico

 

 

An Open e- letter to the Honorable Representative Martin Heinrich of New Mexico

 

Re: Request to Amend H.R.2598 to Include the U. S. military personnel from the Philippines in granting of the Congressional Gold Medal to the WW11 Bataan, Corregidor and Luzon POWs

 

 

Hon Martin Heinrich

1505 Longworth HOB
Washington, D.C. 20515 

 

Dear Sir:

 

My name is Maria Elizabeth Embry from Antioch California, I respectfully call your attention to H.R. 2598 which you had introduced in the U.S. House of Representatives on May 21, 2009, to grant a Congressional Gold Medal to the American military personnel who fought in defense of Bataan/Corregidor/Luzon between December 7, 1941 and May 6, 1942.

 

Allow me to respectfully inform your Honor, that as a passionate advocate for the U.S. Armed Forces personnel of Filipino descent, that I am deeply troubled about the irreconcilable conflict in the language used in H.R. 2598. If you may recall American military personnel include those who are natives of the Philippines, as well as those who were drafted or who had enlisted in the Philippines in the U.S. Armed Forces before and during WW11 and subsequently fought in defense of Bataan/Corregidor/Luzon between December 7, 1941 and May 6, 1942

 

However, your Congressional Findings Section 2(a) of H.R. 2598, defined the intended recipients of the Congressional Gold Medal, to quote “Award Authorized….in honor of the soldiers from the United States who were prisoners of war at Bataan/Corregidor/Luzonin recognition of their personal sacrifice and service to their country”

 

Sir, I am respectfully requesting that the exclusionary provision be amended to include all members of the U.S. Armed Forces who were prisoners of war at Bataan/ Corregidor/Luzon without taking into consideration their place of nativity and domicile, as well as their race and citizenship since none of these were considered when they were drafted or when they enlisted.

 

The Congressional Findings Section 1 (7) of H.R. 2598 stated the following: “within the first 40 days at Camp O'Donnell, 1,600 more prisoners from the United States died. Missing are the significant statistics for the prisoners of war from the Philippines.

 

Your Honor, according to the Office of the U.S. Provost Marshall General Report on American Prisoners of War interned by the Japanese in the Philippines dated November 19, 1945 “about 1500 American and 22,000 Filipino prisoners of war died at Camp O’Donnell from starvation, disease and the brutal treatment received at the hands of the captors.” This same report further stated that, “from 10 Apr 1942 to 5 May 1942 (6 weeks) nearly 1600 Americans and 26,768 Filipinos died from lack of quinine and food, (although) the Japanese Army had plenty of food and medicine on hand.

 

Sir, honoring only those who suffered further captivity is to diminish the role of those who were paroled, but nonetheless suffered the same and sometimes actually worse fate than the military personnel you are honoring exclusively.

 

With all due respect to your Honor, allow me to remind you of the following facts:

 

The U. S. WW11 Bataan POW from the Philippines, although paroled, continued fighting to victory an unwinnable war against all odds sans military equipment, organization and hope.

 

They fought the ravages of malnutrition, war related illnesses, exposure to further arrests and endangerment to their person, family and friends.

 

They lost their homes that became shells of abode destroyed equally by enemy and friendly fires.

 

They helped rescue the POWs, that not for the courage of rescuers the likelihood of not finding a single soul to save among them is a real possibility given the known propensity of the enemy soldiers.

 

They reenlisted to help clean up postwar Okinawa and other places, maintained peace and order, rebuilt and saved United States numerous territorial possessions from anarchy and further devastations.

 

They came back from war not to the accolades but to the resounding rejection from the U.S. Congress that their wartime service was deemed not to have been a service to the United States military and as a consequence suffered the indignity and humiliation of being excluded by a nation regarded in the whole world for her democratic principles.

 

They embarked patiently on a 63 year journey thru numerous U.S. courts and congressional floors to fight for the recognition, with the steadfast support of legislators like the Hon. Inouye, Akaka, Filner, Honda and many others who incidentally include many of the co sponsors of H.R. 2598

 

They watched many of their comrades die with their military service unrecognized, excluded from education, health care and housing benefits enjoyed by their comrades from other nationalities and later they were not allowed burial with military honors in military burial grounds.

 

Sir, the WW11 U.S. military personnel from the Philippines suffered all these and many more unspeakable indignities.

 

Although, I would like to say that I trust your good judgment, however, I would like to respectfully caution your Honor not to go in the same path taken by your predecessors in Congress who fashioned the two infamous Rescission Acts of 1946 in deliberately excluding the Filipino WW11 U.S. veterans from the honor they deserved as a matter of law and conscience. Let there be no more divisions among the military personnel who had honorably served United States cause. Why perpetuate the inequity?  Why not render justice now, since we are fortunate enough to find these remaining valiant Filipino WW11 U.S. veterans still with us?

 

I would appreciate a written response from your Honor regarding these issues.

 

 

Sincerely,

 

Maria Elizabeth Embry

xxxxx

Antioch Ca 94509

Tel xxxxx

 

http://cgmedal4-bataanpow.tripod.com

http://filipinos-ww2usveterans-4equity.tripod.com

http://filipinos-ww2usmilitaryservice.tripod.com

 

copy provided to

Speaker Nancy Pelosi

all co-sponsors of H.R.2598

 

 

 

RE: H.R. 2598 POWs @ Bataan introduced by Rep Martin Heinrich

Tuesday, June 9, 2009 8:46 AM
From:
To:
 
Dear Mr. Sandoval,
 
Sir, thank you so much for your kind response. I am confident that when Congressman Heinrich realizes the implication of  the exclusionary provision of H.R. 2598, that he will amend the bill.
 
I became hopeful after reading what Congressman Heinrich had written, to quote:
 
"When my father was just a boy, his parents fled Nazi Germany and immigrated to the United States. The older I get the more I realize how much that history shaped my dad's world view and informed the values he and my mother taught me. At an early age, I gained a real appreciation for our Constitution, our Bill of Rights, and our civil liberties. In my family, patriotism wasn't just about how high you could fly the flag, but rather how effectively you could live up to the democratic ideals that our flag and our country represent" MY STORY, OUR LIBERTIES by Martin Heinrich
 
Please give my personal message to Rep Heinrich that the U.S. flag is flying high and proud today, only because the POWs  from the United States including the POWs from the Philippines serve United States cause in the hallowed grounds of Bataan, Corregidor and Luzon.
 
My sincere gratitude to your kind attention to this matter.
 

Maria Elizabeth Embry

RE: H.R. 2598 POWs @ Bataan introduced by Rep Martin Heinrich

Monday, June 8, 2009 11:52 AM
From:
To:
maria.embry@sbcglobal.net

Thank you for the e-mail, Ms.Embry.

I will pass this information along to the Congressman.  I will keep posted of any developments.

Regards,

Antonio

Antonio E. Sandoval

U.S. Representative Martin Heinrich (NM-01)

20 First Plaza NW, Suite 603

Albuquerque, NM 87102

Phone: 505-346-6781

antonio.sandoval@mail.house.gov

http://heinrich.house.gov/

 

 

FAIR USE

Pursuant to Title 17 U.S.C. 107, other copyrighted work is provided for educational purposes, research, critical comment, or debate without profit or payment. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for your own purposes beyond the 'fair use' exception, you must obtain permission from the copyright owner

WEBSITE UNDER CONSTRUCTION